Title

V.2.3 - Nominal-value principle

Content

No. V.2.3 - Nominalistic principle

Unless otherwise agreed by the parties, a claim for payment in a certain currency entitles the creditor only to the contractually specified amount of that currency (nominal value), irrespective of any fluctuations of the currency in which the debt is expressed between the date of concluding the contract out of which the claim arises and the date of payment.

Commentary

1 This Principle means that every debtor has to pay a monetary debt at its nominal value. Therefore, without any special agreement of the parties in their contract, each party carries the risk of currency depreciation if he is to receive under a contract a payment in a currency other than the currency of his home country.

2 Commentary No. 4 to Principle V.2.4 explains how the parties may cope with the exchange rate risk by inserting an exchange rate adjustment clause ("value-stabilization clause" or "index-linking clause") into their contract.

References

Doctrine

Fouchard, Philippe, L'Arbitrage Commercial International, Paris 1965

Eckstein, Felix, Geldschuld und Geldwert im materiellen und internationalen Privatrecht (1932), p. 124 et seq.Nussbaum, Arthur, Vertraglicher Schutz gegen Schwankungen des Geldwertes - Goldklauseln und andere Abreden zur Minderung des Valutarisikos, 1928Proctor, Charles, Mann on the Legal Aspect of Money, Oxford 2005.The Nominalistic Principle - A Legal Approach to Inflation, Deflation, Devaluation and Revaluation (1971), p 37 et seq.van Houtte, Hans, Changed Circumstances and Pacta Sunt Servanda, in: Gaillard (ed.), Transnational Rules in International Commercial Arbitration (ICC Publ. Nr. 480,4), Paris 1993, at 105 et seq.

Court Decisions

BAG NJW 1973, 959 et seq.OLG München ZUM-RD 2018, 208 et seq.

Arbitral Awards

Hamburger Freundschaftliche Arbitrage, Award of May 2, 1977, YCA 1979, at 202 et seq.ICC Award No. 505, World Trade, October 1932, at 11.ICC Award No. 513, World Trade, October 1932, at 10 et seq.ICC Award No. 519, World Trade, December 1932, at 11.ICC Award No. 534, World Trade, February 1933, at 10 et seq.ICC Award No. 536, World Trade, May 1933, at 11.ICC Award No.1704, Clunet 1978, at 976 et seq.

National Legislation

Nieuw Burgerlijk Wetboek - New Netherlands Civil Code ( Dutch Civil Code )Philippines Republic Act 386 (Civil Code)

Contract Clauses

1. Contractual Clause Departing From Nominalistic PrincipleServices Contract